ASTRAL WINDS FORUMS

this is a list of proposals to clarify exactly what constitutes going through a ring. a bit more general than simply projectiles.

personally, i'd like the other option for the althing to be "we delegate responsibility for weapon safety to the champion/GMR."

no one posted a distinct wording other than the one i posted at the beginning. i apologize valegorn you were close but i do not know what X is, the variable is unclear.

the reason i delayed the poll this long is because i was the only one to submit something. i'm not sure if it's possible to add an option to the poll but if you post something and it's possible for me to edit the poll i will add your attempt at wording, up until monday.

option 2 is there because it requires me to offer 2 options. no matter how many people vote for it it will not be submitted.

I put "x" because I was going to let someone else put in a number that seemed reasonable. I just wanted a cube that wouldn't be illegal if you trimmed the corners a bit, as I understand it, the current cubes become illegal if you cut down the corners, if the cube was bigger, then maybe this could solve that problem.

say;

"a cube can be no smaller then 9 cubic inches, (I think thats right, which ever it is where each surface is no smaller then 3x3 inches.) with the corners nipped"


I know it's probably too late, but you get what i'm trying to get at.

I would recommend that this be delayed pending the outcome of the Circle of Monarchs meeting this summer. There are multiple discussions that are relevant and being led by none other than Dragonspine's own Sir Phocion presently on E-sam.

Changing the rules now will only create additional confusion in a couple months when again there is a new review.

Additionally, there shouldn't need to be a discussion on whether or not to delegate safety to the Champion/GMR. That's their role in the first place. It would be like voting to delegate awards authority to the Monarch.

GoldCrest

Edited to include:
These are the posts I'm referencing above:
I. Defining injury http://www.electricsamurai.com/forums/v ... 11&t=21267
II. Core Reserve http://www.electricsamurai.com/forums/v ... 11&t=21268
III. Foam requirements http://www.electricsamurai.com/forums/v ... 11&t=21270
IV. Striking Surfaces, sizes, and "passing through the ring" http://www.electricsamurai.com/forums/v ... 11&t=21272
V. Plastidip http://www.electricsamurai.com/forums/v ... 11&t=21273
(and I notice Gorin has already included one of these in the other discussion)

I totally agree with Goldcrest. We should probably put it off till we see what comes out of Clan.